 |
|
American Pie
No long discussion: We don't have to talk about Madonnas version of American Pie. She can't make it to create the same atmosphere with this song as Don McLean did 30 years ago. In may opinion also the voice of a man fits much better to this song. It is a folk song for the campfire and not a song for Madonna, the Queen of Pop.
Or do you have another opinion?
Madonna
2000 |
vs. |
Don McLean
1971 |
| Click on the cover for listening |
|
Click on the cover for listening |
Comments about American Pie:
I kinda like madonna's better...
- stephanie, chilliwack, Canada, 19.04.2008 |
When I heard that Madonna had covered this song, I thought it would have to be horrific. But, bizarrely enough, her version is much less terrible than I expected. I actually kind of like it.
- TheGrammarFairy, Indiana, United States, 09.04.2008 |
What the ...? Some idiot out there actually voted for Madonna?? Even Madonna wouldn't vote for Madonna..
- Robert Sinatra, Phoenix, United States, 06.03.2008 |
I agree with Patrick
- Zach, Rolla, United States, 06.02.2008 |
Madonna's version is missing just one thing: Her tongue on my butthole.
- Patrick M., St. Louis, United States, 06.02.2008 |
Its "But February made me shiver" dumbass. I heard while eating at TGI Fridays and had to go to the bathroom and throw up. Madonnas version is god awful
- Jim, Rome, United States, 18.01.2008 |
I hope everyone's heard the (Bob Rivers, I think) parody, "Oh, why did Madonna kill American Pie?"
- Matthew, Ottawa, Canada, 06.12.2007 |
Madonna straddled this song and pissed all over it, all for the sake of having something to add to a shitty vanity project of a film. Boo.
- Brian Otano, Brooklyn, United States, 07.11.2007 |
Don is the best !!!! Madonna destroys one of the best songs ever !!! Shame on you Madonna !!!!!!
- Robert Minnebo, Dendermonde, Belgium, 03.11.2007 |
I would put even the Brady Bunch's washed out, white-bread cover of "American Pie" ahead of Madonna's verson.
- Mark, Boston, United States, 11.10.2007 |
|
