Cover vs. Original

Smooth Criminal

Thanks for this proposal, Tom. I have to admit, when I first read the name of the song, I didn't know which song it is. But then I started listening to it and I recognized it of course. But that the version by Alien Ant Farm is only a cover version and that Michael Jackson wrote the original, I haven't known so far. But you live and learn.
However, I like this song. But I'm not a big fan of Michael Jackson. So my vote goes to Alien Ant Farm.

Alien Ant Farm


Michael Jackson

CD-Cover: Alien Ant Farm - Anthology 49.9 % 50.1 % CD-Cover: Michael Jackson - Bad
Results of the voting: Cover versus Original
Click on the cover for listening Click on the cover for listening
Alien Ant Farm 8721 Votes Michael Jackson

Comments about Smooth Criminal:

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
as.. honestly.. how many people even like michael jackson after the whole going on trial for well.. u kno.. and even tho proven not guilty... its hard to recover your reputation after something like that.. but then people that grew up listening to michael jackson.. are most likely to pick his version... because.. they grew up with it.. so.. yea.
- Madison, Gayville, United States, 5-.-0.2007
I believe that even though the "statistics" say that AAF's song is better, the original of all songs is always better. and "statistics" only work truly if everybody votes. it could be that only a small bit of people voted and that's the conclusion. so SUCK OFF!
- anonymous, City, United States, 4-.-0.2007
Being a musician for 20 years, I can understand that some groups do covers for many reasons. Usually, it is either the challenge, or a liking of the song done by the original artist(s).... like a tribute. I do, however, find it amazing that some of the covers are even included on the album/CD. At some point the group has to listen to the final mix and make a decision. Guns and Roses' version of "Knocking on Heavens Door " comes to mind, and now this one. It would appear that the group doing the cover should have said.... "naw... this really sucks", and be honest. Obviously not done in either case mentioned above. I'd give AAF a "C" for the effort (G&R gets an "E Minus")but neither should have been released. The fact that it was causes me to not want to listen to any of their other stuff.
- Zappafan, Cleveland, United States, 4-.-0.2007
As far as the ratings go, I think the one done by AAF is better than MJ, but as far as the music video goes, both are kinda lacking. AAF's video spoof of MJ is funny as hell, but has no storyline to it. As far as MJ's vid goes, I guess you have to be from that era to understand it. Either way, Smooth Criminal rocks!
- Gnanmorder, Perrysburg, United States, 4-.-0.2007
I like Alien Ant Farm's version better but you can't not respect the original Micheal Jackson created it. But Alien Ant Farm's version is more the style i like.

Some of micheal Jacksons other songs are great.
- Tarni, Brisbane, Australia, 2-.-0.2007
i like to hear smooth criminal.
- shamil, shah alam, Malaysia, 2-.-0.2007
Alien ant farm is ugh.. nvm..

Michael Jackson is way better no lie..
- Julia, NYC, United States, 2-.-0.2007
Even if he touched children, MJ is the lesser of two evils here. That's how awful AAF is.
- Goatboy, Scarborough, England, 1-.-0.2007
I think that MJ's original is much more atmospheric and dramatic. It was one of his best songs in my opinion. I love the AAF cover. It is heavy and raw. I vote that the original is better however. Bands usually do covers because they think the songs are great as well, so I'll bet that AAF would agree
- Super Dave, New Roads, LA, United States, 1-.-0.2007
You All Have wonderfull comments. But like I voted, and the majority of others as well, AAF takes the cake on this one. Sorry Mike....wahooo.
- William, eagan, United States, 2-.-1.2006
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
««« Top
Wärmeisolierung Smooth jazz for dinner events, conventions and wedding parties.