 |
|
Whiskey in the Jar
Thin Lizzys version is a classic song, but Metallica is more powerful! A hard decision!
- Rocko, Nürnberg, Deutschland, 13.02.2006
Metallica
1998 |
vs. |
Thin Lizzy
1973 |
| Click on the cover for listening |
|
Click on the cover for listening |
Comments about Whiskey in the Jar:
both versions are awesome!!! i love the guitar on thin lizzy's version, and james hetfields vocals are incredible on the metallica version. maybe if we combined them we could have the best version ever...???
- Mickey Seddon, Auckland, New Zealand, 30.08.2007 |
thin lizzy a classic seen the band at a gig in bridgend s. wales 1972/73 became a fan and have always been a fan sat and talked to the great phil lynott at the gig MAGIC
- taff charles, stocton on tees, United States, 20.08.2007 |
Sometimes, the classic is best.
- Shane, Montgomery, United States, 20.07.2007 |
saw metallic play it in dublin gr8
saw lizzy play it on live and dangreous tour awesome
Saw Eric Bell play it wiv Brush Shields
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
- Baz, Belfast, Ireland, 07.07.2007 |
I have to give this one to Thin Lizzy. Phil's voice fits it better, he sounds more sincere over the events that happen in the song. Whereas James is just being James. While I will agree Metallica the Thin Lizzy version is too good.
- Tracy, Seattle, United States, 02.07.2007 |
the thin lizzy version is better than metalica's as is Luke Kelly's and Pogues/Dubliners
thin lizzy wrote the music for their version and changed some of the lyrics
metallica did a cover of the lizzy song but left out the intro and don't sing the first chorus
- badger, tralee, Ireland, 08.05.2007 |
the thin lizzy version is better than metalica's as is Luke Kelly's and Pogues/Dubliners
thin lizzy wrote the music for their version and changed some of the lyrics
metallica did a cover of the lizzy song but left out the intro and don't sing the first chorus
- badger, tralee, Ireland, 08.05.2007 |
Thin Lizzy are gods.
- Dan, London, England, 06.04.2007 |
Both bands are great but, the thin lizzy version is of course better, Eric Bell kicks butt on that solo as does Hammett but they just cant compete with classic Thin Lizzy and Lynotts vocals are awesome too.
- Dan, London, England, 06.04.2007 |
In History* lol
- Pete Gidman, Leicester, England, 29.03.2007 |
|
