Cover vs. Original

Sweet Child O' Mine


Some think it's sacrilege, but I'm just a sucker for Sheryl Crow. I like her twangy sound over the hard rock original. Plus I like ballsy covers.

- Matt, New York, United States, 16.10.2005


Sheryl Crow
1999

vs.

Guns N' Roses
1987

CD-Cover: Sheryl Crow - Big Daddy 18.3 % 81.7 % CD-Cover: Guns N' Roses - Appetite For Destruction
Results of the voting: Cover versus Original
Click on the cover for listening Click on the cover for listening
Sheryl Crow 2219 Votes Guns N' Roses

Comments about Sweet Child O' Mine:

1 2 3 4 5 6
First Sheryl tells me how much toilet paper i should use, then she goes and produces shit herself!! The 2nd worst cover of all time (AFI's version of GN'Rs My Michelle is worse) For fucks sake will some one please kill her!!!!!
- Martin Raper, Hull, England, 06.11.2007
Wow...Redoing this song is like trying to make an un-funny joke funny! Maybe Cheryl Crow covered it for laughs, but you just can't shake the musty ol' basement feel off this crappy tune. Back around late '87 when these pricks when national (& I guess world-wide sadly) only pre-teens & complete dirt bags were into this shit. Nowadays this an example of a song for those whom are either uneducated rejects, or can't clap on beat. Boy oh boy, I don't miss this train-wreck of a band. Why did he insist on singing like that? What the fuck inspired such whinny shitty lyrics? Why did all those bands dress like that? Answer...they were trying to be cool & tough. Cool guys just are (ex. Dag Nasty) & there's nothing more useless than a tough guy (ex. pro wrestlers)
- Jenny D'Inofrio, Swampscott, Massachusetts, United States, 07.10.2007
We can't deny the geniality and the power within Guns And Roses' version, besides, the introductory solo is like an icon in modern rock; but let's admit it: Sheryl Crow's is not that bad! Ok, there's NO way in comparing both versions, but we can't be that "purist"...She did a nice version of the song.
- Eric Rodríguez, Mexico City, Mexico, 30.09.2007
I can't stand Gun N' Roses but who on earth covers them in the first place?
Sheryl Crow needs to stick to her own songs.
I hate every cover she's ever done.
- Roni, Laguna Hills, United States, 23.07.2007
There are some songs you just don't get away with covering. This is definitely one of them.
- Skunk, nyc, United States, 18.04.2007
Dude You can't even compare these two. Nothing beats the Guns N'Roses version.
- Anna, London, England, 04.04.2007
Love em both... Sheryl's is easier to sing along with...
- Ellie, Memphis, United States, 14.03.2007
I bet Sheryl was doped with some of Lance's magic stuff when she picked this one for a cover. Bad, bad idea.
- Rash, Chicago, United States, 24.02.2007
Why can't someone feed that talentless twat to slash's fucking snake!!! For the love of god WHYYYY!!!
- Chad, Worcester, United States, 05.02.2007
I LOVE GUNS N' ROSES !!!
- Air Bear BABY !!!, Toronto, Canada, 28.01.2007
1 2 3 4 5 6
««« Top