Have A Cigar
Even though they had Brian May... they cannot top the original!
- Gero, Rietberg, Deutschland, 30.07.2007
Foo Fighters
1999 |
vs. |
Pink Floyd
1975 |
| Click on the cover for listening |
|
Click on the cover for listening |
Comments about Have A Cigar:
I just found out that Roy Harper sang on this one(PF). I had always thought it was Roger Waters. Anyway, his madman vocals make the song. I also love Gilmour's guitar work and the opening is one of the coolest sounding things in classical rock. The Foo Fighters' version is awful.
- JD, Atlanta, Ga, United States, 28.10.2010 |
Perfection can't be improved! It's a nice try but... sorry Fighters!
- andré, tábbua, Portugal, 06.10.2010 |
my all time favorite band is foo fighters, but the original is just so much more famous, so ill have to go with pink floyd here.i cnt believe im sayin this
- cody, selden, United States, 12.02.2010 |
My favorite bands but pink floyd version is better
- Dani, Budapest, Hungary, 27.06.2009 |
foo fighters kill and will one day be more legendary than pink floyd. their music is so much better
- Rory, Hawkes Bay, New Zealand, 21.08.2008 |
Foo Fighters - a good band. Pink Floyd - a legened. Not much of a choice here. In fact I don't think anyone could better a Pink Floyd song.
- Giuseppe, Bucharest, Romania, 23.04.2008 |
You r fucking retarted. Foo Fighters cant touch pinkfloyd with an 80 mile long pole. Pink Floyd Rules!!
- Sam, San Francisco, United States, 11.12.2007 |
Foo Fighters version kicks pink floyds ass anytime allthoug foo fighters standard are more crappy music than pink floyd...
- Søren, Glamsbjerg, Denmark, 13.10.2007 |
