Cover vs. Original

Nothing Else Matters


Mmmh, here we have really a brazen pop-singer - just my opinion.

- Christian, Trier, Deutschland, 10.01.2006


Lucie Silvas
2005

vs.

Metallica
1991

CD-Cover: Lucie Silvas - Breath In 28.2 % 71.8 % CD-Cover: Metallica - Metallica
Results of the voting: Cover versus Original
Click on the cover for listening Click on the cover for listening
Lucie Silvas 2957 Votes Metallica

Comments about Nothing Else Matters:

1 2 3
Any Metallica fan who hates this song, is just not a Metallica fan. It was written for some forgotten girl at first, but it has become Metallica's song for their fans. It's an amazing song, beautiful chord progression, a tasteful solo and heart felt lyrics. No cover can compare to the original.
- Nekuro, Durban, South Africa, 30.09.2010
pointless cover and not very well executed either ..
- Paul, Berlin, Germany, 19.02.2010
the metallica one is def. better... but there IS a version out there of the metallica song with a female voice added into it... sounds kinda like amy lee, from evanescence... but I cant find any record of it online... whoever it is, It sounds AWESOME... like it was always meant for 2 ppl to sing it
- Dan, Oshawa, Canada, 30.05.2009
the metallica one is def. better... but there IS a version out there of the metallica song with a female voice added into it... sounds kinda like amy lee, from evanescence... but I cant find any record of it online... whoever it is, It sounds AWESOME... like it was always meant for 2 ppl to sing it
- Dan, Oshawa, Canada, 30.05.2009
Superbad cover... when I hear the intro I always hope it's the original... then this idiot comes on... her next hit: Breathe in, Breathe out... yes bitch otherwise I die... dumb fuck...
- Mormel, Utrecht, Netherlands, 07.12.2008
One of the shittiest songs of Metallica from one of their shittiest albums. But still, the original is WAY better than this piece of musical mucusLucie Silvas slimed into her microphone...
- Daniël, Amsterdam, Netherlands, 21.11.2008
Pah. Metallica wins hands down. But being honest, i don't mind her version, it's actually good. I mean, atleast she didn't turn it into some crappy dance remix with a gangster rap in the middle somehow relating it to "the hood" and that idiotic ultra high pitched chipmunk effect on the voice...........
- Pete, London, England, 26.09.2008
What the hell was she trying to doing?
Metallica for life, no one is better then Metallica dudes, what are you guys thinking on? OH MY GOD!
- Free17, Lisbon, Portugal, 10.06.2008
There's no way any cover version of this song can be better than the original.
- Giuseppe, Bucharest, Romania, 23.04.2008
I like metallica but i also dont think lucie silvas is that bad. i have to say that i think both versions are good; at least lucie silvas did something different with it, i dont think you could call it a rip-off because its not like shes imitating metallica. i have both versions on my ipod and i listen to them both equally depending on what mood im in
- Phebe, London, England, 22.01.2008
1 2 3
««« Top