 |
|
I Will Survive
Cake's version of this oft karaoked song slows it down and puts a bit of rock into it.
- temujin71, Colorado Springs, CO, United States, 04.03.2006
Cake
1996 |
vs. |
Gloria Gaynor
1978 |
| Click on the cover for listening |
|
Click on the cover for listening |
Comments about I Will Survive:
the cake version is funny but the original has more meaning to the lyrics
- jayden, NYC, United States, 22.10.2008 |
for those non-CAKE-knowing bitches in here, I'd just like to say that Cake's version is very original. Great bassline, lead and trumpet. Have you heard most of the covers today? What they do is just add distortion and they change the singing to shouting and that's it. Cake did something very different with this song, and it had always been John Mccrea's technique to sound boring. This for me is a matter of preference , but musically speaking, he creates some of the prettiest melodies. Have you guys heard the songs "the distance" and "love you madly?".. Try to tell me if they're boring at all. They're songs are very different and if you're a good musician then you'd learn to appreciate how these guys play and create music. Just like in this song, they added a bit of creativity by making it sound a bit more funkier and slower, I can't believe how underrated cake is nowadays. People listen to boy bands and stupid pop artists but fail to appreciate good bands when they see one.
- mohamed etits, KANTUTAN, Iraq, 04.08.2008 |
Cake is ALWAYS boring. 3-note singing, usually. What a terrible thing to do to the word "cake!"
- Kelly, Omaha, United States, 21.03.2008 |
Cake's version is much more interesting to listen to musically. The bass is simple but outstanding in their version. Original is musically boring - although the energy is outstanding and it is always fun to dance to.
- Adam, Denver, United States, 28.02.2008 |
CAKE, how can you survive when you sound so lazy singing the song? musical brilliance notwithstanding, you SUCK!
- Mr. Kent, Jakarta, Indonesia, 21.12.2007 |
I remember the firast time i heard the cake version: i pulled the car over to fully take in the brilliance! His amazing sense of timing is unmatchable... what is hillarious is to hear cover band do a version of survive, and attempt to do the Cake one - totally destroying the offbeat way it was reworked and oblivious to the ORIGINALITY of the cake cover!
- Misterpig, Sydney, Australia, 19.08.2007 |
Gloria Gaynor's vocals certainly have more passion and feeling (matching the lyrics) than John McCrea does for Cake. That being said, I voted for Cake, because the musical instrumentation kicks ass. And as a Sacramentan I'm very biased...
- Dave C, Sacramento, California, United States, 24.03.2007 |
For me Gloria Gaynor's version is superior. It has this great energy. The Cake one is funny the first time you hear it but then gets really boring...
btw I hated the Robbie version :-S
- Judith, Leiden, Netherlands, 24.11.2006 |
I just can't swallow Cake's style, sounds like crap to me. I don't think it would be hard to make a good cover of this song, but cake's surely isn't it.
Consider looking into Robbie William's Love Supreme, he changes the lyrics but is the exact same song.
- JA, Chicago, United States, 25.08.2006 |
Gloria version ---> better !!!
- Kika, Geneva, Switzerland, 22.08.2006 |
|
