Without You
Mariah's version injects more emotion into the song. You feel the gut-wrenching emotion, as Nilsson's version is more macabre.
- Charlie, Cincinnati, OH, United States, 03.05.2007
Mariah Carey
1994 |
vs. |
Harry Nilsson
1971 |
| Click on the cover for listening |
|
Click on the cover for listening |
Comments about Without You:
Harry Nilsson sings this song beautifully.Mariah sounds like an amateur,compared to him.Also like the original by Badfinger.
- Dan, Austin, United States, 10.11.2009 |
To all those who say Nilsson's version is the best u r seriously need to get your ears checked. Mariah made that song her own! Nilsson's version is boring & lacks the emotion & power that Carey's version displays.
- Kyle, Perth, Australia, 17.07.2009 |
The ORIGINAL version by BADFINGER will never be topped by Nilsson, Carey or anyone. Probably the most underrated band ever.
- Iñaki, Barcelona, Spain, 29.03.2009 |
Beautiful song made all the more beautiful by Mr. Nilsson and utterly destroyed Miss Piggy.
- Martin, London, England, 16.02.2009 |
It is obvious that Mariah was inspired by Nilsson's version. She says she heard the song as a little girl. So inspiration alone should make the best cover go to Nilsson. But the quality and depth of Nilsson just makes it a slam dunk.
- Pascal Redfern , Missoula, United States, 14.01.2009 |
QUE MANERA DE DESTRUIR UNA CANCION Y QUE VALOR O DESFACHATES DE MARIAH DE ATREVERSE A CANTAR ESA CANCION.
OBVIAMENTE LA MEJOR ES LA DE NILSSON SIN LUGAR A DUDAS
- oscar, mexico city, Mexico, 21.10.2008 |
Nilsson's version is nice but is a cover by itself. Original version by Badfinger is the very best.
- Welkie, Maastricht, Netherlands, 20.06.2008 |
Harry Nilsson's version without a doubt simply destroys Mariah's. Sure, she can sing... but Harry's version has 100 times the emotion behind it.
- G.Weapons, North Country, United States, 11.05.2008 |
The original by Badfinger is the best
- gerard, valkenswaard, Netherlands, 02.05.2008 |
Harry Nilsson version is very better than Mariah's
- Ivan, Plovdiv, Bulgaria, 05.04.2008 |
