Cover vs. Original

Don't Cry for Me Argentina


Julie's voice and range in this song is far superior in this song but my friends disagreed so I thought I'd put it up for the vote.

- Adam Gray, Newcastle, UK, England, 18.11.2007


Madonna
1996

vs.

Julie Covington
1976

CD-Cover: Madonna - Evita The Complete Motion Picture Soundtrack 19.3 % 80.7 % CD-Cover: Julie Covington - Evita Original London Cast Recording
Results of the voting: Cover versus Original
Click on the cover for listening Click on the cover for listening
Madonna 549 Votes Julie Covington

Comments about Don't Cry for Me Argentina:

I agree with Kevin. Superior orchestration with the movie version, but no one on this planet can top the talent of Julie Covington. On a 10 out of 10 rating, she rates a 100 in my opinion. Listen to her beautiful voice on the original version (especially "Buenos Aires") and you will agree!
- John Kunzer, Granger, United States, 18.08.2010
I agree with Kevin. Superior orchestration with the movie version, but no one on this planet can top the talent of Julie Covington. On a 10 out of 10 rating, she rates a 100 in my opinion. Listen to her beautiful voice on the original version (especially "Buenos Aires") and you will agree!
- John Kunzer, Granger, United States, 18.08.2010
Julie does have a better vocal quality to her voice than Madonna, however, I do disagree that the original cast recording has the better overall album. The music on the motion picture version has much more depth & a richer sound than the original.
- Kevin, Greenville, United States, 16.07.2010
Origineel natuurlijk!
- Evita, London, England, 08.03.2010
ANYONE is better than Madonna
- Jennifer, Snurgleville, United States, 18.08.2009
There is no comparison. Madonna sounds like an amateur compared to Julie Covington.
- Ex-pat, Bangkok, Thailand, 07.08.2008
Julie Covington was a WONDERFUL Evita. Madonna did okay.
- Freya, Ghent, Belgium, 12.06.2008
Julie's version is the best. The original album period is the best. Julie's voice is so powerful and natural.
- Paul, North Carolina, United States, 29.12.2007
De acuerdo contigo regina jejeje
- Cartoncho, Lima, Peru, 06.12.2007
me sumo hacia la version de julie jjejjeee
- regina, lima, Peru, 06.12.2007
««« Top