Cover vs. Original

When The Stars Go Blue


I like both and there are other covers of this song including one by The Corrs and Bono. The original just sounds more believable.

- Bryan Cody, Raleigh, United States, 16.11.2005


Tyler Hilton & Bethany Joy Lenz
2005

vs.

Ryan Adams
2001

CD-Cover: Tyler Hilton & Bethany Joy Lenz - One Tree Hill 60.1 % 39.9 % CD-Cover: Ryan Adams - Gold
Results of the voting: Cover versus Original
Click on the cover for listening Click on the cover for listening
Tyler Hilton & Bethany Joy Lenz 1836 Votes Ryan Adams

Comments about When The Stars Go Blue:

1 2 3 4
I love the version of Tyler Hilton becouse I am ONE OF THE FENS of ONE TREE HILL
- Diddy, Sofia, Bulgaria, 07.06.2008
How is this even a poll?!
- steve, burlington, United States, 12.03.2008
ryan adams never gets any credit...its a shame. i remember last season on american idol someone sang this song and gave credit to tim mcgraw or some shit, but no mention of ryan adams......people are retards
- ryan, new jersey, United States, 21.11.2007
I love this song by bethany joy and tyler hilton.I like glad and other songs they sing, like leaving town alive.
- Julieta, Buenos Aires, Argentina, 05.11.2007
Anyone with a name like Tyler or Bethany needs to be executed.
- Fred Thompson, Nashville, Bulgaria, 31.10.2007
i love the cover ant it is so much better than the org.
- maria, gävle, Sweden, 24.09.2007
When I first heard this song from the Corrs I dont like it. But when I heard the revival from Tyler and Bethany I learned to love it and I start playing it in guitar. I love the melody and the blending of their voice. And of course I';m one of a big fan of one tree hill. I already have DVDs from season 1 to 4 and also I have their sountracks. I love Bethany Joy Lenz-Galeotti as Haley James Scott. I memorized all her 3 songs that she sang in OTH. (Halo, elsewhere and this When the Stars go Blue)

Im from Philippiens. c",)
- Nicole, San Francisco, United States, 17.09.2007
Agreed. Tyler Hilton is a decent singer but the Ryan Adams version is awesome. Listen to Wild Flowers from Gold as well - brilliant.
- Dan, Sheffield, England, 20.08.2007
Seriously... are you fucking serious!?!?!? This is Ryan Adams Song, and he has written over a hundred songs that are just as insightful. You all need a lesson in music. Ryan Adams is probably the greatest Singer/Songwriter of our time... GET A FUCKING CLUE YOU TEENIE BOPPERS!!!
- Jeremy, Denver, United States, 19.08.2007
ok ay loking three hill in whan episode ay hrt this song eng this song is the best song ever this seiBethany Joy Lenz & Tyler Hilton -
- petar, budva, Serbia, 08.08.2007
1 2 3 4
««« Top